Undandy has a smaller selection of designs on offer with only five styles to pick from, but they still offer a wide range of options when it comes to the color (over 50 to pick) and shoe decoration. Unlike Idrese who cater to all types of men, Undandy is more for the gentleman who enjoys wearing a classic style of shoe, such as a custom dress shoe or custom moccasin.

Custom-made shoes from Undandy start from $208 and ship worldwide, so no matter where you are in the world you can grab yourself a pair or two.  

3. Allen Edmonds

Rating: 3.5/5

Our third selection and most expensive (custom-made shoes start from $495), Allen Edmonds cater to those with cash to burn. Founded in 1922, the American brand is a leader in custom-made men’s dress shoes. They count several US Presidents amongst their dedicated customers.

Design your Own

Allen Edmonds only has seven styles to choose from, with the majority on the dressier side of things. As with the other brands mentioned on this list, once you have chosen your style of shoe, you then have several options when it comes to the decorations and look of the shoe, before settling on the size and width. 

The construction of the shoes uses full-grain leather so you know you are getting the best materials on the market. Allen Edmonds sources its leather from the top tanneries across the globe and is known for featuring single leather soles on its custom dress shoes for a sleek, lower profile.

Allen Edmonds, along with Idrese, are terrific brands for those who want custom shoes for wide feet, as they offer an extensive selection of widths so you can make sure your custom-made shoe or custom-made boot fits as it should.

Conclusion

Custom made shoes are becoming more and more popular these days, with these three brands all crafting luxurious custom-made shoes for any occasion. While both Undandy and Allen Edmonds are expert shoemakers with decades of experience crafting custom-made shoes, it is hard to look past Idrese when it comes to picking the best of three. Not only do they use premium full-grain leather and Goodyear welt construction, but the choice of shoe styles available far surpasses the other brands. We give Idrese’s personalized shoes two thumbs up!